Requirements

Must be available currently in printed physical form (Print on Demand (PoD) is okay). PDF is a nice additional option, but must have easily purchased physical option.

 Must support "heroic play" aka "white hat". Prefer good in-game behavior modification consequences for non-heroic play. 

Looking Into

• Boot Hill RPG by TSR
• Boot Hill 2 by
• Boot Hill 3 by
• Aces & Eights by Kenzer & Company (same people that make Hackmaster)
• Western Hero by Hero Games
• GURPS Old West by Steve Jackson Games
• Dust Devils RPG by Chimera Creative
• Gunslingers RPG by Gold Rush Games
• Dead in the West RPG by
• Deadlands by AEG/Pinnacle (can it be easily stripped down to remove the mystical items?)
• Snakes & Saloons by Snakes & Saloons
• Legends of the Untamed West by Dark City Games Inc.
• Coyote Trail by Precis Intermedia
• Gunslingers & Gamblers by
• Wild West RPG by ...
• Wild West by Fantasy Games Unlimited
• Shotguns & Saddles by
• Wild West Cinema by
• Desperados by Skycastle Games
• Western by Lancelot
• Outlaw (Rolemaster system) by Iron Crown Enterprises
• Far West (Spanish) (BRP system) by
• Burros & Bandidos by Sierra Madre Games
• Basic West by Stratelibri
• Werewolf: The Wild West (can the mystical be stripped out easily enough?)
• The Devil's Addition (SABM) by Knuckleduster games
• The Legacy of Zoro by Gold Rush Games
• Cold Steel Reign by
• Link: West by
• Dogs in the Vinyard by
• OGL Wild West by
• 1887 -Sob o sol do Novo Mexico by
• Old West (Ubiquity system) by

Evaluation Results

Rejected

References

http://ageofravens.blogspot.com/2016/03/history-of-wild-west-rpgs-first-fifteen.html

https://forum.rpg.net/index.php?threads/best-rpg-for-authentic-old-west-action.751249/